Beef broth begins as bones, meat and water, which makes it look like the easiest halal question in the kitchen. The conditions published by Singapore’s Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura (MUIS) point somewhere else: to how the cattle were slaughtered, and to everything else that went into the pot.
MUIS lists “Animals that are not slaughtered according to Islamic requirements” among its non-Halal food categories, so under MUIS’s categories, broth made from cattle that were not slaughtered Islamically is non-halal. MUIS also defines Halal as lawful or allowable, and says most food and drinks are Halal unless the Quran and Hadith clearly state them as forbidden. MUIS’s conditions for processed food, published for Singapore, turn on four things: the slaughter, the ingredients, the equipment, and keeping halal food separate from everything else.
What is beef broth, and how does it differ from stock and bone broth?
Beef broth is the liquid left after beef bones and meat simmer in water, often with onions, carrots, celery, herbs and spices. It forms the base of soups, stews, sauces and rice dishes.
The names overlap in everyday cooking. Stock usually leans on bones, often roasted first, and runs richer and thicker. Bone broth simmers bones for longer still. Commercial broth, sold in cartons, cans, cubes and powders, adds a further layer: flavourings, preservatives and other additives that the home cook never chose.
Each version raises the same halal questions. Where did the animal come from? What else is in the liquid? What did it touch on the way to the bowl?
What makes beef broth halal or non-halal under MUIS rules?
MUIS sets out conditions a processed food must meet to count as “halal”. They apply to a carton of beef stock as much as to any other packaged food, and they reach well past the meat itself.
Does the beef have to be slaughtered a certain way?
Yes, according to MUIS. Its first condition says a processed food is halal only if the product or its ingredients does not contain “any components or products of animals that are non-Halal by Shariah Law or animals that are not slaughtered according to Shariah Law”.
That wording matters for broth. The condition covers any components or products of an animal, not only its meat, so under MUIS’s test the bones and fat in a stock depend on the same slaughter question as the beef.
Which ingredients can make a beef broth non-halal?
MUIS lists intoxicants, such as alcoholic beverages, and swine, such as pork and lard, among its non-Halal food categories. Wine is an alcoholic beverage, and some cooks use it to deglaze a roasting pan or deepen a stock.
Under MUIS’s conditions, quantity offers no escape. Its second condition requires that a halal processed food “does not contain anything in large or small quantities that is considered as non-halal according to Shariah Law”. A splash of wine in a large pot, or a little lard in a flavour base, still counts under that test.
Does shared kitchen equipment matter?
MUIS says it does. Its conditions require that halal processed food be prepared, processed or manufactured using equipment and facilities that are free from cross-mixing with non-halal substances.
The separation continues after cooking. MUIS states that during preparation, processing, storage or transportation, the product should be fully separated from any food that does not meet its requirements. For broth, that covers the stockpot, the filling line and the delivery truck alike.
How does JAKIM treat gelatin and collagen in certified food?
Long simmering draws collagen and gelatin out of beef bones, and some commercial broths may contain gelatin. In Malaysia, Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (JAKIM) has set out specific paperwork for both.
In an announcement dated 30 April 2021, JAKIM said that applicants and holders of Malaysia Halal Certification (SPHM) that use collagen or gelatin must, besides having a recognised halal certificate and a DNA lab-analysis report, attach a technical document confirming the original source of the collagen and gelatin when they apply. JAKIM listed four options: a product specification, a product description, a Material Safety Data Sheet or a Technical Data Sheet.
The announcement covers manufacturers that use collagen or gelatin as a raw material or ingredient, and those that make collagen- or gelatin-based end products. A broth maker seeking Malaysian certification that adds gelatin as an ingredient falls in the first group. For more on the ingredient itself, see our guide asking whether gelatin is halal and where it comes from.
What should you do when a broth’s halal status is unclear?
MUIS has a name for the grey zone. It classes grey-area ingredients as Syubhah, and its own example is lecithin, which MUIS considers Halal when it comes from plants but non-Halal when it comes from pigs or from animals not slaughtered in accordance with Islamic law. MUIS’s guidance is direct: until the status becomes clear, Muslims should avoid consuming Syubhah food or drinks.
Flavourings, fats and additives in a commercial broth can raise the same question of origin. The questions to put to a manufacturer follow MUIS’s conditions: how the cattle were slaughtered, whether any ingredient comes from a non-halal source, and whether production lines are shared with non-halal food.
Eating out raises the same questions with less visibility. In Singapore, MUIS provides a search of Halal-certified eating establishments and food preparation areas, which lets diners check a restaurant before ordering a beef soup or a noodle broth.
Is bone broth halal, and is homemade broth any different?
Bone broth is beef broth made with more bones and more time. MUIS’s first condition covers “any components or products of animals” that are non-Halal or not slaughtered according to Shariah Law, wording that takes in bones as well as meat.
Homemade broth puts each of those checks in the cook’s own hands. The cook chooses the butcher, the bones, the deglazing liquid and the pot. Store-bought broth hands those choices to a manufacturer, and MUIS’s four conditions for processed food become the questions to ask of it.
Related reading: What Is Halal? What the Quran and Hadith Say, and How It Works Today | Is Chicken Powder Halal? | Is Chicken Soup Halal? What to Know About Halal Broths
Author
