For most U.S. Muslims with $10,000 or more to invest, the cheapest halal setup is a plain brokerage account rather than a halal app. SP Funds’ SPUS charges 0.45 percent a year, or about $45 on $10,000, at a commission-free broker such as Fidelity or Schwab. Wahed’s robo-advisor costs more than three times that once its fund fees are counted.
Why the headline fee is the wrong number to compare
The fee a platform advertises is rarely what you pay. Total cost has up to four layers: the platform or advisory fee, the expense ratio of each fund inside the account, any subscription you pay for screening, and account charges such as IRA custodial fees. A cheap app holding expensive funds can cost more than a pricier fund held at a free broker.
Wahed is the clearest case. Its U.S. pricing page lists a wrap fee of 0.49 percent plus $60 a year for balances under $100,000, falling to 0.49 percent alone above that. Wahed’s U.S. FAQ states that the expense ratios of the ETFs and mutual funds in its portfolios are “not included” in that wrap fee. Investors pay them separately through the funds.
Those funds are mostly Wahed’s own. The Wahed FTSE USA Shariah ETF (HLAL) carries a 0.50 percent expense ratio and the Wahed Dow Jones Islamic World ETF (UMMA) 0.65 percent, according to Wahed’s fund pages in November 2026. A $10,000 Wahed account therefore pays about $109 in wrap fees plus roughly $50 to $65 in fund costs, or $159 to $174 a year. The exact fund layer depends on each portfolio’s mix of equity, sukuk and gold funds, which Wahed does not publish as a single blended figure.
The strongest objection: a robo-advisor rebalances for you, and that discipline has value. It does. But at $10,000 the $60 fixed fee alone is 0.60 percent of the account, more than the entire annual cost of SPUS. Pay for automation only if you know you will not rebalance on your own.
Total annual cost by platform and fund, November 2026
The table below lists what each option costs per year before purification, using each provider’s own pricing or fund pages as of November 2026. Dollar figures assume a $10,000 balance. Commission-free brokers add nothing to ETF costs for online trades.
| Platform or fund | Type | Annual cost | Cost on $10,000 | Minimum | Screening body | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SP Funds SPUS (U.S. equity) | ETF | 0.45% | $45 | One share | AAOIFI standards; ShariaPortfolio methodology | SP Funds fund page |
| Wahed HLAL (U.S. equity) | ETF | 0.50% | $50 | One share | Yasaar (index); Wahed Shariah Supervisory Board | Wahed fund page |
| SP Funds SPSK (sukuk) | ETF | 0.50% | $50 | One share | AAOIFI standards | SP Funds fund page |
| SP Funds SPRE (REITs) | ETF | 0.50% | $50 | One share | AAOIFI standards | SP Funds fund page |
| SP Funds SPWO (ex-U.S. equity) | ETF | 0.55% | $55 | One share | AAOIFI standards | SP Funds fund page |
| Wahed UMMA (global ex-U.S.) | ETF | 0.65% | $65 | One share | Wahed Shariah Supervisory Board | Wahed fund page |
| Amana Growth, Investor (AMAGX) | Mutual fund | 0.86% | $86 | $100; none in IRAs | Saturna Capital screens | Saturna fund page |
| Amana Growth, Institutional (AMIGX) | Mutual fund | 0.61% | n/a | $100,000 | Saturna Capital screens | Saturna fund page |
| Amana Participation, Investor (AMAPX) | Mutual fund (sukuk) | 0.81% | $81 | $100; none in IRAs | Third-party sukuk review | Saturna fund page |
| Iman Fund (IMANX) | Mutual fund | 0.99% net (1.29% gross) | $99 | $250; $100 in IRAs | North American Islamic Trust (adviser) | Sept. 30, 2026, prospectus |
| Wahed robo-advisor (U.S.) | Managed account | 0.49% + $60 under $100,000, plus fund costs | $159 to $174 | $100 | Wahed Shariah Supervisory Board | Wahed pricing page and FAQ |
| Musaffa managed investing | Managed account | $10 a month at $5,000 to $14,999; 0.75% at $15,000 to $99,999 | $120, plus any fund costs | $500 | Musaffa | Musaffa pricing page |
| Musaffa self-directed | Brokerage with screening | $5 a month under $24,000; 0.25% to 0.10% above | $60, plus fund costs | Not stated | Musaffa | Musaffa pricing page |
| Zoya Pro | Screening subscription | $119.99 a year or $14.99 a month; App Store also lists annual offers from $59.99 | $60 to $120 | None | Zoya | Zoya help center; App Store listing |
Two patterns stand out. Every flat monthly charge, whether Wahed’s $60, Musaffa’s $5 or $10, or Zoya’s subscription, hits small accounts hardest. And the four SP Funds ETFs plus HLAL sit in a narrow band of 0.45 to 0.55 percent, so the choice among them should turn on what the fund holds, not on a fee gap of a tenth of a point at most. Our comparison of Shariah-compliant ETF fees covers holdings, fund size and the newer Amana ETFs in more detail.
How costs change at $100,000
At $100,000 the ranking holds, but the gaps shrink in percentage terms. SPUS costs $450 a year. Amana Growth’s Institutional shares, which open at exactly $100,000, cost $610. Wahed drops its $60 fixed fee and charges 0.49 percent, or $490, plus about $500 to $650 in fund expenses, for a total near $990 to $1,140.
Musaffa’s self-directed tier charges 0.20 percent between $100,000 and $499,999, or $200 a year, on top of whatever funds you hold. Its pricing page hides the managed-investing rates above $100,000 behind a toggle and says fees fall “as low as 0.45%” without naming the balance where that applies.
Small percentages compound. Assuming a 7 percent annual return before fees, $100,000 grows to about $356,000 over 20 years at a 0.45 percent total cost and to about $318,000 at 1.05 percent. That gap of roughly $38,000 is larger than most fund-picking decisions will ever produce. Returns will differ, but the direction will not.
Purification costs less than any fee in the table
Purification, the donation of the share of dividend income that came from impermissible sources, is often treated as a hidden cost of halal investing. In practice it is the smallest line on the bill, because it applies to dividends rather than to the whole balance.
SP Funds publishes quarterly purification factors calculated under AAOIFI guidelines. For the second quarter of 2026, the factor was 1.66 percent of dividends for SPUS, 1.41 percent for SPWO, 0.42 percent for SPRE and zero for SPSK, which holds only sukuk. If a $10,000 SPUS position paid $100 in dividends in a year, the purification amount would be about $1.66. That is 0.017 percent of the balance, roughly one-twenty-seventh of the fund’s expense ratio.
The SP Funds purification calculator states that the company does not deduct purification from investor accounts, citing possible tax consequences, so the donation is the investor’s job. Saturna takes a similar approach for the Amana funds, publishing annual per-share factors as of each May 31 fiscal year-end. Scholars and screening bodies differ on details, such as which income counts as impure and whether capital gains also need purifying, so readers with a specific question should ask a qualified scholar.
The limitation: purification is easy with a fund that publishes a factor and tedious with a portfolio of individual stocks, where you must find each company’s impure income yourself. Our guide to how to tell if a stock is halal explains the screening ratios behind those numbers. That difficulty is the strongest case for paying a screening app, and it applies mainly to stock pickers.
When a screening subscription is worth paying for
A screening app such as Zoya or Musaffa answers one question: is this individual stock compliant today? If you hold only SPUS, HLAL or an Amana fund, the fund’s own Shariah process already answers it, and a Zoya Pro subscription at $119.99 a year adds 1.2 percent to a $10,000 account. That is more than double the cost of the fund itself.
The subscription makes sense for investors who buy individual stocks and want compliance alerts, ratio data and dividend purification tracking in one place. Musaffa’s pricing FAQ says its paid plans include purification and zakat calculators. Zoya’s help center lists the U.S. price of Zoya Pro at $14.99 a month or $119.99 a year, and its App Store listing in November 2026 showed those prices alongside cheaper annual offers starting at $59.99.
What we would not recommend: a new investor with $5,000 paying both a screening subscription and a robo-advisor. Together they can consume 3 percent or more of the account each year.
The low-fee choice concentrates you in five tech companies
Cheap does not mean diversified. Shariah screens drop conventional banks, insurers and heavily indebted companies, which pushes index weight toward large technology firms with little debt.
As of Nov. 18, 2026, SPUS held 14.13 percent in Apple, 10.35 percent in Nvidia and 10.34 percent in Microsoft, according to SP Funds. Its top five holdings, including Alphabet and Broadcom, made up about 44 percent of a fund of roughly 200 stocks. A sharp fall in technology shares would hit SPUS harder than a broad S&P 500 fund.
The trade-off is real. Adding SPWO for non-U.S. stocks and SPSK for sukuk raises the blended expense ratio only slightly, to about 0.50 percent with equal weights, and spreads the risk. Wahed’s portfolios and the Amana funds offer broader mixes at higher cost. For the principles behind these choices, see the five essentials of halal investing.
IRA access can matter more than a few basis points
For U.S. investors, the cheapest fund outside a tax-advantaged account can cost more after taxes than a slightly pricier one inside an IRA. Most of the options above work in an IRA, but the account fees differ.
- Fidelity says it charges no account fees and has no minimums for retail brokerage accounts, including IRAs, and both Fidelity and Schwab charge $0 commissions on online U.S. stock and ETF trades.
- Wahed offers Traditional, Roth and SEP IRAs and rollovers from $100, but its FAQ says IRA and other custodian fees fall outside the wrap fee.
- The Iman Fund charges a $15 annual IRA custodial fee per account, capped at $30 per Social Security number, according to its Sept. 30, 2026, prospectus.
- Amana’s Investor shares have no minimum in tax-sheltered accounts, according to Saturna.
- M1 charges a $3 monthly platform or IRA fee unless total assets reach $10,000 on at least one day of the billing cycle, according to M1’s help center in March 2026.
The $15 Iman fee looks trivial but equals 0.15 percent on a $10,000 IRA, which erases most of the gap between Iman and a cheaper mutual fund. For a broader view of where these products sit in Islamic finance, see our guide to Islamic finance and fintech.
What U.K. investors pay instead
U.K. investors face a different menu, built around ISAs, U.K. robo-advisors and Irish-domiciled UCITS funds rather than the U.S. products above.
Wahed U.K. charges the higher of 1 percent a year or 2.99 pounds a month on portfolios up to 250,000 pounds, 0.75 percent from 250,000 pounds to 1 million pounds and 0.5 percent above that, with a 50-pound minimum to open, according to its U.K. help center. The iShares MSCI World Islamic UCITS ETF (ISWD) carried an ongoing charge of 0.30 percent on Nov. 19, 2026, according to Fidelity International’s U.K. fact sheet, before any platform fee. Our review of Shariah-compliant platforms in the U.K. compares Wahed with IslamicFinanceGuru, Simply Ethical and Yielders.
Which option we would pick at each balance
Under $10,000: a commission-free brokerage IRA holding SPUS, or SPUS with SPWO for diversification. Skip robo-advisors and screening subscriptions; the flat fees cost more than the funds.
From $10,000 to $100,000: the same ETF core, with SPSK if you want a sukuk sleeve. Choose Wahed only if you value automatic rebalancing and accept paying roughly 1.6 percent a year at $10,000 and about 1.1 percent at $100,000.
Above $100,000: compare SPUS or HLAL against Amana’s Institutional shares at 0.61 percent, which add active stock selection by Saturna Capital for an extra 0.16 points over SPUS. Before moving money, check each provider’s current fee page, because the Wahed, Musaffa and Zoya figures above can change without a new prospectus.



