Malaysia keeps halal certification inside one government chain: the Department of Islamic Development Malaysia (JAKIM) and the state Islamic religious departments audit, decide and issue the certificate. Indonesia splits the work three ways. Indonesia’s Halal Product Assurance Organizing Agency (BPJPH) issues the certificate, the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) or a government fatwa committee rules on halal status, and accredited inspection bodies run the audits.
The shorthand “JAKIM vs. MUI” is seven years out of date. Until Oct. 17, 2019, MUI’s own institute, LPPOM MUI, did run Indonesian certification and MUI signed the certificates. That changed when Law No. 33 of 2014 on Halal Product Assurance took effect for certification and moved the issuing power to BPJPH, a state agency. MUI kept the part that matters most to Muslim consumers: the ruling on whether a product is halal.
For exporters, the distinction is a business question. Indonesia makes certification a legal condition for most consumer goods sold in the country, and its trade minister, Budi Santoso, said on Sept. 17, 2026, that Indonesia had signed mutual recognition agreements with 116 foreign halal bodies out of 199 that applied, according to the state news agency Antara. Malaysia keeps certification voluntary for most products but polices who may use the word halal, and JAKIM recognized 93 foreign certifiers in 48 countries as of August 2025, its director general, Sirajuddin Suhaimee, told reporters at the Global Halal Summit in Kuala Lumpur. Our reading: Indonesia’s system is cheaper per certificate and harder to plan around; Malaysia’s costs more over time but changes less often.
How Malaysia’s system works
In Malaysia, the government agency that audits a company is the same one that decides the product is halal and prints the certificate. JAKIM handles multinationals, exporters and foreign applicants, while the state Islamic religious departments (JAIN) and councils (MAIN) certify most local small businesses in their states.
The legal basis is the Trade Descriptions Act 2011 and two orders made under it in the same year: the Trade Descriptions (Definition of Halal) Order 2011 and the Trade Descriptions (Certification and Marking of Halal) Order 2011. The second order names JAKIM, MAIN and JAIN as the only competent authorities that may certify halal for goods and services in Malaysia, which is why a company cannot simply print its own halal claim. Audits follow the Malaysian Halal Certification Procedure Manual 2020 (MPPHM 2020), the Malaysian Halal Management System 2020 and product standards such as MS 1500:2019 for food.
Speed has been the standing complaint. Deputy Prime Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, who chairs the Malaysian Halal Council, said on Sept. 13, 2023, that he had heard of applications taking nine months to two years, and he told JAKIM that every application must get a decision within 30 working days, Sinar Harian reported. Our guide to JAKIM’s application process walks through the MYeHALAL portal steps, audit and committee review.
How Indonesia’s system works
In Indonesia, no single body controls a certificate from start to finish. A company applies to BPJPH through its SIHALAL portal, a halal inspection body (lembaga pemeriksa halal, or LPH) audits the plant, MUI’s fatwa commission rules on halal status, and BPJPH then issues the certificate.
LPPOM MUI remains the best-known inspection body, but it now competes with other accredited LPHs. The fatwa can come from MUI’s central fatwa commission, a provincial or district MUI, or the Aceh ulama council. The Job Creation Law, Law No. 6 of 2023, added a fourth option: a government-appointed Halal Product Fatwa Committee that rules on products in the self-declare route for micro and small businesses, and on regular applications when MUI misses its statutory deadline. Religious Affairs Minister Yaqut Cholil Qoumas set up the committee’s interim team on March 20, 2023, and it issued about 78,948 halal determinations in roughly 40 days, BPJPH said on May 9, 2023.
The agency itself has also moved. Presidential Regulation No. 153 of 2024 turned BPJPH into a nonministerial agency that reports directly to the president instead of sitting inside the Ministry of Religious Affairs, according to BPJPH’s own profile page. Ahmad Haikal Hasan heads it. That change gave halal policy more political weight in Jakarta, and it also means the rules now come from an agency still writing its procedures as it goes: BPJPH issued a new decree on foreign certificate registration on Sept. 15, 2025, then a 2026 regulation on import conformity assessment that the government said in October it plans to revoke.
Side-by-side comparison
The table below sets out the main structural differences as of Oct. 30, 2026. Fee figures come from each country’s official schedule; consultancy, training and laboratory costs come on top.
| Feature | Malaysia | Indonesia |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | Trade Descriptions Act 2011; Definition of Halal Order 2011; Certification and Marking of Halal Order 2011 | Law 33/2014, amended by Law 6/2023; Government Regulation 42/2024 |
| Certificate issuer | JAKIM (federal) and state bodies (JAIN/MAIN) | BPJPH, reporting to the president under Presidential Regulation 153/2024 |
| Who rules on halal status | The certifying authority’s halal panel, guided by national and state fatwas | MUI (central, provincial or district) or Aceh’s ulama council; Halal Product Fatwa Committee for self-declare and missed deadlines |
| Auditors | JAKIM and state officers | Accredited LPH bodies such as LPPOM MUI |
| Procedure and standards | MPPHM 2020; Malaysian Halal Management System 2020; MS 1500:2019 (food) | Halal product assurance system set by BPJPH regulations |
| Validity | Fixed term by category: two years for food and beverages, one year for slaughterhouses; monitoring at least once a year | Valid from issue for as long as ingredients and halal production process do not change |
| Official fee | RM20 processing fee per application, plus RM100 to RM1,000 a year for products, by company turnover (MPPHM 2020) | Rp0 for self-declare; regular route priced from audit days, product category and operational costs (BPJPH tariff decree as amended in 2024) |
| Mandatory? | Voluntary for most goods; only competent authorities may certify a halal claim | Mandatory for goods entering, circulating or traded in Indonesia, phased by category to 2034 |
| Logo | Single national JAKIM halal logo | National Indonesian Halal Label (purple), mandatory since March 1, 2022 |
| Self-declare route | None | Yes, for eligible micro and small firms with low-risk products |
| Foreign certifiers | 93 recognized bodies in 48 countries (August 2025) | 116 signed mutual recognition agreements (September 2026) |
Mandatory in Indonesia, voluntary in Malaysia
Indonesia requires halal certification by law for products that enter, circulate or are traded in the country, while Malaysia leaves it to companies, except that any halal claim must come from a competent authority. A company in Malaysia can sell uncertified food; it simply cannot call that food halal.
The Indonesian obligation is phased. Large and medium food and beverage producers came under it on Oct. 17, 2024. Products that are not halal do not need a certificate, but they must carry a non-halal statement. In practice, Malaysian supermarket chains and Muslim shoppers enforce a market standard almost as strict as Indonesia’s legal one, so the voluntary label in Malaysia is less optional than it sounds for mass-market food. The pressure is weaker for cosmetics and household goods, where uncertified brands still sell well.
The broader question of what halal certification actually covers, from ingredients to storage and logistics, applies in both countries; the difference is who checks it and what happens if a company skips it.
What certification costs
Malaysia’s official fees are flat and published. Under Section 8 of MPPHM 2020, product makers pay a yearly certification fee set by annual turnover: RM100 (about $24 at Bank Negara Malaysia’s rate of roughly RM4.09 per dollar on Oct. 9, 2026) for micro companies with turnover below RM300,000, RM400 for small companies, RM700 for medium companies and RM1,000 (about $245) for companies with turnover above RM50 million. Each application also carries a RM20 processing fee, or RM200 for foreign-registered companies manufacturing in Malaysia, and a foreign company that has products contract-manufactured in Malaysia pays a one-time RM2,500 (about $611) if it is based in Southeast Asia or RM10,000 (about $2,445) if it is from elsewhere. Our breakdown of JAKIM fees and hidden costs covers food premises, hotel kitchens and the consulting, training and staffing expenses that usually exceed the official fee.
Indonesia prices the regular route by the job. BPJPH’s tariff decree, No. 141 of 2021 as amended for the third time in 2024, sets the self-declare route for micro and small businesses at zero rupiah. For everyone else, the bill is built from the number of auditor-days, a unit cost per auditor-day that depends on the product category, and operational costs. The amended schedule lists unit costs from Rp3,937,000 (about $219 at the rate of about Rp18,014 per dollar that Katadata reported on Oct. 16, 2026) for slaughter services to Rp21,125,000 (about $1,173) for vaccines, and operational costs of Rp960,000 (about $53) for medium companies and Rp1,440,000 (about $80) for large ones. Foreign companies also pay auditors’ travel and accommodation at Finance Ministry rates. A foreign certifier seeking recognition pays Rp17,500,000 (about $971) for each accreditation, conformity assessment or surveillance step.
Government fees are the smallest part of either bill. A large manufacturer’s real costs sit in hiring a halal executive, reformulating around an uncertified ingredient and paying for audits. On that measure, Indonesia’s open-ended validity is the bigger saving: a company that never changes its recipe never faces a scheduled renewal audit there. A Malaysian food certificate runs for two years and a slaughterhouse certificate for one, and the authorities monitor certified companies at least once a year, according to the Islamic religious affairs department of the state of Negeri Sembilan.
Does Indonesia recognize JAKIM, and does Malaysia recognize BPJPH?
Yes, in both directions, but through each country’s general foreign-recognition rules and a 2023 cooperation memorandum rather than a merged system. JAKIM and BPJPH signed a Memorandum of Cooperation on mutual recognition of halal certification for domestic products on June 8, 2023, under which each would list the other as a recognized certification body.
The memorandum was signed for Malaysia by Hakimah Mohd Yusoff, then JAKIM’s director general, and for Indonesia by Muhammad Aqil Irham, then head of BPJPH, according to JAKIM’s June 8, 2023, media statement. The statement said Malaysian products bearing JAKIM’s logo could enter Indonesia, and Indonesian products bearing BPJPH’s logo could enter Malaysia. It covers goods made in each country, not third-country products that a Malaysian or Indonesian company re-exports.
On April 22, 2025, after meeting President Prabowo Subianto in Jakarta, Hamidi said the two governments had agreed in principle that JAKIM’s logo could be used on halal products exported to Indonesia without a separate standard operating procedure, and that Malaysia would recognize Indonesian certification for exports to Malaysia, Free Malaysia Today reported. We could find no signed text or published procedure for that April 2025 arrangement, so exporters should treat it as political intent until BPJPH or JAKIM publishes implementing rules.
Recognition still requires paperwork. Under BPJPH Decree No. 221 of 2025, an importer must register a foreign halal certificate in SIHALAL before the goods circulate in Indonesia, and the registration lapses if the foreign body’s mutual recognition agreement expires. The same logic of recognition between halal certifiers runs the other way: Malaysia’s 2011 certification order allows imported products to carry a halal claim only from a foreign body on JAKIM’s gazetted list.
The deadlines exporters now face
Imported food, beverages, slaughtered products and slaughter services now face Indonesia’s mandatory certification from Oct. 18, 2028, not October 2026. Susiwijono Moegiarso, secretary of the Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs, announced the two-year extension in Jakarta, Antara reported on Oct. 17, 2026, citing the readiness of the halal industry.
The same change, an amendment to Article 160 of Government Regulation No. 42 of 2024, moves domestic micro and small food businesses to Oct. 17, 2028, and gives herbal medicines, quasi-drugs, health supplements, cosmetics, chemical products, genetically engineered products and certain consumer goods the same Oct. 17, 2028, date. Over-the-counter medicines keep a phased deadline to Oct. 17, 2029, and prescription drugs other than psychotropics to Oct. 17, 2034, Susiwijono said. The government also plans to revoke BPJPH Regulation No. 4 of 2026, which had required conformity assessment for imported halal products. Readers following Indonesia’s phased mandatory certification schedule should read its October 2026 dates for these categories against the extension.
The delay helps Malaysian exporters whose certifier, JAKIM, already holds an active recognition agreement with BPJPH, but it does not remove the need to register each foreign certificate. The extra time matters most to exporters whose certifiers were among the 83 applicants that had not signed an agreement as of September 2026.
Where the two systems still clash
Doctrine is rarely the problem. Malaysian and Indonesian fatwa institutions both work mainly within the Shafi’i school of Islamic law (a madhhab, one of the four main Sunni schools of jurisprudence), so disputes between the two countries’ halal authorities tend to be about procedure, scope and logos. Each country’s fatwa bodies still rule separately, so a product approved in one market has to pass the other’s review before it can carry that market’s logo.
Speed against scrutiny is the deeper split. Indonesia’s self-declare route and its fatwa committee moved tens of thousands of micro-business products through certification in weeks, a pace no audit-based system can match. Before the committee existed, Sholahuddin Al-Aiyub, who heads MUI’s Shariah economy and halal division, said in October 2021 that self-declared products must still pass through MUI’s fatwa commission because a halal certificate is, in his words, “a written fatwa.” Law 6/2023 settled that argument against MUI. Malaysia’s audit-first model is slower, and every certificate still rests on an on-site inspection. Our position: for an exporter choosing where to certify first, a JAKIM certificate remains the more portable credential, while BPJPH certification is the one Indonesia’s law requires at home.
The open item for 2027 is whether JAKIM and BPJPH turn the April 2025 logo agreement into a published procedure before Indonesia’s Oct. 18, 2028, import deadline, so a Malaysian manufacturer can ship with one logo instead of two.



